Every so often, prominent figures in tech begin amplifying the same topic so energetically that it makes you wonder if they’re all on the same group chat (or if the hive mind from “Pluribus,” the Apple TV+ sci-fi show, is a real thing). One such moment occurred this past week, when it became hard to escape the deafening online chatter about data centers in space.

That was in large part thanks to Elon Musk, who began promoting the concept through a series of posts on X. It isn’t just Musk hyping the concept, though. Amazon executive chair and founder Jeff Bezos and former Google CEO Eric Schmidt have both been big believers for a while. Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has also jumped on the bandwagon.

Last month, Google, one of the biggest cloud providers, said it plans to launch prototype satellites by 2027 to see how its AI chips, called tensor processing units, perform in space. And this week, a space data center startup, Starcloud, said it had trained the first large language model in space aboard a demonstration satellite outfitted with an Nvidia graphics processing unit.

On one hand, this is an exhilarating vision, especially if you’re a sci-fi nerd. But there’s also a more pessimistic interpretation of the sudden enthusiasm of so many smart, powerful AI barons for sticking data centers in space—namely, they don’t think the U.S. can meet the compute needs of the AI industry on terra firma. That makes sense, as we’ll explain. First, though, we should acknowledge that some of the proponents of data centers in space—Musk in particular—have other agendas.