AI Startups Are Facing a ReckoningRead more

Illustration by Mike Sullivan

Facebook’s Decade-Old Missteps Should Be a Lesson for Web3

Photo: Illustration by Mike Sullivan

Once upon a time—that is, in 2011—the company then known as Facebook launched Open Graph, a way for users to carry their Facebook identities from app to app, thereby enabling developers to give them a personalized experience wherever they went. Rather than recreating an identity each time you went to a new app, you could leverage the identity you had already built through Facebook and—at least in theory—the sum total of Open Graph developers leveraging the platform.

Sub “crypto wallet” for “Facebook account” and the goals of Web3 are shockingly similar. Both Open Graph and the decentralized web constitute attempts to address the same deep gaps around identity and memory in the internet as it was originally conceived. Both aim to enable portable identity across digital ecosystems, including data, assets and relationships. And hard as it may be to believe given the tenor of today’s discourse, even the idea of personal data sovereignty that’s so central to the crypto world was baked into the Open Graph vision.

Despite the company’s high-minded aspirations, Facebook’s Open Graph efforts didn’t work. This was for a handful of reasons, some of which could have been anticipated, others of which were more subtle, and none of which had to do with the fact that Facebook was a centralized entity. That’s not to say that the difference between a single company providing this cross-platform service versus a decentralized, blockchain-based approach isn’t consequential—just that it’s not determinative on its own. The new crop of technologists building Web3 still has a lot to learn from the problems with Facebook’s Open Graph.

Access on the go
View stories on our mobile app and tune into our weekly podcast.
Join live video Q&A’s
Deep-dive into topics like startups and autonomous vehicles with our top reporters and other executives.
Enjoy a clutter-free experience
Read without any banner ads.
From left: Paul Graham, Garry Tan and Michael Seibel. Photos by Getty. Art by Mike Sullivan.
Exclusive startups ai
Y Combinator’s Garry Tan Goes to the Mat
Garry Tan was in his happy place. Surrounded by food trucks and techies basking in San Francisco’s September sun, the CEO of Y Combinator snapped selfies with entrepreneurs as he meandered through a crowd of 2,700 attendees at the startup accelerator’s annual alumni event.
Dave Rogenmoser, cofounder of Jasper. Photo via Getty.
Exclusive startups ai
Jasper, an Early Generative AI Winner, Cuts Internal Valuation as Growth Slows
Jasper AI, an early darling of the generative artificial intelligence boom, has cut the internal value of its common shares 20%, according to former employees who were notified by the company.
Dave Rogenmoser, co-founder of Jasper. Photo by Bloomberg via Getty.
AI Agenda ai
AI Startups Are Facing a Reckoning
A reckoning may be coming for once-hot artificial intelligence startups. Among the most vulnerable: consumer apps (think Character.AI) and “thin wrapper” startups like CopyAI that merely provide a nice user interface on top of a third-party model from model developers like OpenAI.
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang. Photo by Getty
Exclusive semiconductors ai
Nvidia Deepens Push Into AWS’ Turf
Nvidia’s ambition to compete with Amazon Web Services is growing. Nvidia is best known for designing server chips for artificial intelligence, but it has been running a nascent cloud service for corporate customers that develop AI with those chips.
Sam Altman and Mark Zuckerberg. Photos via Shutterstock and AP.
Meta, OpenAI Square Off Over Open Source AI
Artificial intelligence leaders and policymakers are divided on a key question: Are cutting-edge AI models too powerful to hand to just anyone?
The X (formerly Twitter) office in San Francisco on July 29. Photo by Bloomberg via Getty.
policy
Musk’s X Cuts Half of Election Integrity Team After Promising to Expand It
Elon Musk’s X, formerly known as Twitter , is cutting around half of the global team devoted to limiting disinformation and election fraud on the platform, including the head of the group, according to three people familiar with the situation.