Exclusive: Tiger Global, Alkeon Slash Startup Valuations Amid Public Stock Selloff Read Now

Illustration by Mike Sullivan
Modest Proposals
Crypto Facebook

Facebook’s Decade-Old Missteps Should Be a Lesson for Web3

Photo: Illustration by Mike Sullivan

Once upon a time—that is, in 2011—the company then known as Facebook launched Open Graph, a way for users to carry their Facebook identities from app to app, thereby enabling developers to give them a personalized experience wherever they went. Rather than recreating an identity each time you went to a new app, you could leverage the identity you had already built through Facebook and—at least in theory—the sum total of Open Graph developers leveraging the platform.

Sub “crypto wallet” for “Facebook account” and the goals of Web3 are shockingly similar. Both Open Graph and the decentralized web constitute attempts to address the same deep gaps around identity and memory in the internet as it was originally conceived. Both aim to enable portable identity across digital ecosystems, including data, assets and relationships. And hard as it may be to believe given the tenor of today’s discourse, even the idea of personal data sovereignty that’s so central to the crypto world was baked into the Open Graph vision.

Despite the company’s high-minded aspirations, Facebook’s Open Graph efforts didn’t work. This was for a handful of reasons, some of which could have been anticipated, others of which were more subtle, and none of which had to do with the fact that Facebook was a centralized entity. That’s not to say that the difference between a single company providing this cross-platform service versus a decentralized, blockchain-based approach isn’t consequential—just that it’s not determinative on its own. The new crop of technologists building Web3 still has a lot to learn from the problems with Facebook’s Open Graph.

Get access to exclusive coverage
Read deeply reported stories from the largest newsroom in tech.
Latest Articles
 
The Briefing Google Policy
The Dangers of War Against Google’s Ad Tech
Alphabet's Mountain View headquarters. Photo by Bloomberg.
Google’s legal department has its hands full these days, given numerous antitrust lawsuits filed both by the Justice Department and individual states targeting different parts of its business. Our scoop today—about how a bipartisan group of senators is putting together a bill to force Google to divest its ad tech operations—will only add to the lawyers’ workload. Where is this all heading?...
Latest Briefs
 
Climate Startups Raised $40 Billion Last Year
Meta Pauses New Users From Accessing CrowdTangle Tool
Airbnb Exec Chris Lehane Joins Katie Haun’s Crypto Fund
Stay in the know
Receive a summary of the day's top tech news—distilled into one email.
Access on the go
View stories on our mobile app and tune into our weekly podcast.
Join live video Q&A’s
Deep-dive into topics like startups and autonomous vehicles with our top reporters and other executives.
Enjoy a clutter-free experience
Read without any banner ads.
Photo by AP.
Exclusive
Tiger Global, Alkeon Slash Startup Valuations Amid Public Stock Selloff
For more than a year, startup founders have watched in awe and some trepidation as hedge funds and other large investors flooded private startups with big checks, pushing up valuations and making it easier than ever to raise money.
Snowflake CEO Frank Slootman (left) and Databricks CEO Ali Ghodsi. Photos by Snowflake, Bloomberg. Collage by Mike Sullivan
Exclusive Cloud
Snowflake vs. Databricks: How Onetime Friends Became Fierce Cloud Rivals
A few years ago, Snowflake and Databricks were up-and-coming cloud software startups that were so friendly, their sales teams regularly passed customer leads to each other.
Pinterest headquarters office in San Francisco. Photo by Bloomberg
Exclusive Entertainment E-commerce
Pinterest Has Lost at Least 7 Senior Execs in Recent Weeks
Pinterest has lost at least seven senior executives in roles ranging from creator marketing to corporate development in recent weeks as the online scrapbooking app grapples with a drop in U.S.
Photos by AP; Bloomberg
Enterprise Markets
M&A Watch: 8 Potential Targets as Tech Stocks Sink
A sharp sell-off in tech stocks over the past few months has caused investors a lot of pain—but could be the trigger for more mergers.
Art by Mike Sullivan
Exclusive Venture Capital Startups
Tech’s Great Headhunter Shortage: Employers Shower Recruiters With Better Pay, Benefits
In the middle of 2020, not long after the Covid-19 pandemic began sparking layoffs across the country, Joe Price watched as eight members of the recruiting department at an automotive software company he worked for lost their jobs.
Art by Shutterstock; Mike Sullivan
Opinion Crypto Economy
Bitcoin Is Failing Its Original Mandate. That Doesn’t Mean It’s Worthless
By plenty of standards, Bitcoin is a failure. Transactions on the Bitcoin blockchain take at least 10 minutes to process, which would make it cumbersome for day-to-day transactions if its wildly fluctuating price hadn’t already rendered it useless as a means of exchange.