Creator Economy
Google Facebook

TI Creator Economy: A Table of Tipping Take Rates; Cameo Gets a New Rival

Online tipping has quietly exploded over the last two years as social networks try to appeal to creators, who are looking for new ways to make money directly from fans. Our latest chart shows how much these features can vary, particularly in the percentage, or take rate, a technology company gets. 

While a handful such as Clubhouse and Twitter aren’t taking a cut, a few get 20% or more of the transactions, suggesting such fees could be a significant source of revenue for some companies. OnlyFans revenue surged 553% to $391 million last year from its 20% cut of fan tips and subscriptions, although it’s not clear how much tipping contributed to the total. 

YouTube takes a 30% cut when fans buy Super Stickers, or animated images that pop up in livestreams. It recently said more than 10 million people bought one of its fan-focused products last year, including channel memberships and pinning comments in live chats.

But tipping can be inconsistent and unreliable, as some Clubhouse creators told me when its payment feature launched in April. “People are not repeat tipping,” said Jonathan Hyla, a filmmaker with 80,000 Clubhouse followers.  

That’s why some social networks are adding animated features that echo those in video games. Twitch, for example, lets users buy packages of virtual goods called Bits, starting at $1.40 for 100 and rising to $308 for 25,000 Bits, that they can sprinkle in during a livestream to cheer their favorite streamers. 

Facebook has a similar system, where it gives creators one cent per every Star they receive. TikTok also lets fans send virtual gifts, such as a disco ball or confetti, during livestreams. This approach, which aims to make the experience of tipping fun, could lend itself to more frequent activity and revenue than a one-time payment to someone’s Twitter Tip Jar. 

Will any of these efforts be enough to get creators to stick around? Online performers have shown they want the option. Many were already adding their Venmo and Cash App payments details to their social media bios before the platforms added tipping. 

Yet there’s a good chance tipping could remain a fringe activity. For a start, fans in some cases, such as when buying Facebook Stars, have to pay extra to shoulder the 30% fee paid to the Apple and Google app stores unless they buy them on desktop browsers. Patreon, notably, is focused on monthly subscriptions rather than tips, though some creators have found workarounds by setting a price of $1 a month for their Patreon pages.

The more lucrative route is probably to focus on subscriptions like these, says Wedbush analyst Michael Pachter, “with users moving to a premium tier to follow the [creators] they like, and the site guaranteeing a minimum.” 

Here’s what else is going on…

Get access to exclusive coverage
Read deeply reported stories from the largest newsroom in tech.
Latest Articles
 
The Briefing Autonomous Vehicles Startups
Way Mo’ Cash for High-Tech Cars
A Waymo minivan arrives to pick up passengers for an autonomous vehicle ride, Wednesday, April 7, 2021, in Mesa, Ariz. Photo: AP
Alphabet’s self-driving car subsidiary Waymo on Wednesday said it raised $2.5 billion from investors, with an asterisk: Alphabet was the lead investor in the round, according to a person familiar with the deal. In Silicon Valley, the lead designation usually belongs to the party that contributed half of the total amount in the round. So either Alphabet CFO Ruth Porat wanted to make sure...
Latest Briefs
 
OnlyFans Seeks Billion-Dollar Valuation
Amazon Blames Social Media Groups For Fake Reviews
Oracle Shares Dip 5% Amid Data Center Buildout Plans
Stay in the know
Receive a summary of the day's top tech news—distilled into one email.
Access on the go
View stories on our mobile app and tune into our weekly podcast.
Join live video Q&A’s
Deep-dive into topics like startups and autonomous vehicles with our top reporters and other executives.
Enjoy a clutter-free experience
Read without any banner ads.
Bird CEO Travis VanderZanden. Photo by Bloomberg.
SPAC Boom Helps Tech Founders Cement Control
When scooter-rental startup Bird goes public later this year, CEO Travis VanderZanden won’t have to worry about the firm’s uncertain prospects emboldening activist shareholders.
Clockwise from top left: Gladly CEO Joseph Ansanelli, The Archivist co-founders Ashley Granada and Joseph Einhorn, Fabric co-founder Ryan Bartley, Smartrr CEO Gabriella Yitzhaek, Shogun CEO Finbarr Taylor, Nacelle CEO Brian Anderson, Fabric CEO Faisal Masud and ReCharge co-founders Oisin O’Connor and Michael Flynn. Photos: the companies.
Startups to Watch Venture Capital Startups
Seven E-Commerce Startups to Watch
As online shopping booms, venture investment in the e-commerce sector has taken off. That has put a spotlight on the small software companies that power online shopping, from enabling product subscriptions to making merchants’ websites run faster.
Gene Farrell, Smartsheet’s chief strategy and product officer. Photo by Bloomberg
The Big Interview Enterprise Amazon
A Former AWS Executive Helps Smartsheet Grow Up
When Gene Farrell left Amazon Web Services four years ago to join a company called Smartsheet, his former employer sued Farrell for violating his noncompete agreement.
Sequoia Capital's offices in Menlo Park, Calif. Photo: Bloomberg
Venture Capital Startups
Is Sand Hill Road Over? No. But Zoom Deals Are Here to Stay
When Andreessen Horowitz finishes construction on its new office in San Francisco’s SoMa neighborhood, its partners shouldn’t expect to find an assigned desk waiting for them.
EzCater CEO Stefania Mallett (l), Kinside CEO Shadiah Sigala (center) and SeatGeek CEO Jack Groetzinger (right). Photos: ezCater, Kinside and SeatGeek
Startups
Three Startups Show How the Pandemic’s Hardest Hit Are Rebounding
Kinside CEO Shadiah Sigala remembers the moment in November when she knew her startup, which helps parents find day care openings, wasn’t just recovering after a tough half year—it was about to take off.
Art: Mike Sullivan
Exclusive Google AI
Google’s Next AI Move: Teaching Foreign Languages
Google CEO Sundar Pichai last month previewed an artificial intelligence model that he said would enable people to have open-ended conversations with technology.