Facebook

What Chris Hughes Got Right and Wrong

I’ve read Facebook co-founder Chris Hughes’s op-ed calling to break up Facebook a few times now and fixate on a different point of his very lengthy argument each time. It’s an ambitious attempt to drawn on history and our own ethical senses to argue that the world would be better off with a far weakened version of the company he helped create.

But the biggest strength of the piece—its personal reflections around Zuckerberg and his power—is also its biggest weakness when it comes to arguing that Facebook should be broken up, the main point of the essay. The purpose of U.S. antitrust law isn’t to depose despots; it’s to preserve competition. And while the two are certainly related, Hughes doesn’t make a compelling case that breaking up the company will fix the abuses and negligence he so rightly identifies.

Get access to exclusive coverage
Read deeply reported stories from the largest newsroom in tech.
Latest Articles
 
The Briefing
Better.com’s Valuation Hopes Reflect Fintech Boom: The Information’s Tech Briefing

There’s something of a boom going on in finance tech startups, you may have noticed. Our scoop today about Better.com, the online mortgage lender, looking to raise money at a valuation of $4 billion—several times where it was last valued—highlights the trend. 

In the past week other startups in the consumer finance market—Affirm, Chime and Robinhood—have each ...

Latest Briefs
 
ByteDance Asks Judge to Block TikTok Ban, Citing ‘Irreversible’ Harms
TPG Buys Sports Sites Amidst Pandemic
Google’s Chronicle Gets Major Cybersecurity Upgrade
Stay in the know
Receive a summary of the day's top tech news—distilled into one email.
Access on the go
View stories on our mobile app and tune into our weekly podcast.
Join live video Q&A’s
Deep-dive into topics like startups and autonomous vehicles with our top reporters and other executives.
Enjoy a clutter-free experience
Read without any banner ads.
Startups Microsoft
Tech Execs Are Obsessing Over Note-Taking Apps. We Tested Them Out
Investors are newly enamored of note-taking apps, financing startups like Notion Labs, Coda and Roam Research at high valuations.
Profile Media/Telecom Markets
Bourkoff Is Star Media Dealmaker, But Can He Make Shift to Tech?
Aryeh Bourkoff hates wasting time. Rather than checking his overcoat when he goes out to lunch during New York’s frigid winters, the investment banker sometimes asks his assistant to walk with him to the restaurant so she can take his coat with her back to the office.
Exclusive Policy Google
In Ironic Twist, Google’s Pro-Privacy Move Boosted U.S. Antitrust Probe
Google has taken a lot of heat for violating people’s privacy. Now it could get in trouble for trying to protect it.
Venture Capital Asia
TikTok Valued at Around $60 Billion, As Deal Structure Emerges
Walmart and Oracle are valuing the soon-to-be formed TikTok Global at between $50 billion and $60 billion, according to two people familiar with the deal, as key aspects of one of the most convoluted global tech deals in history take shape.
The Takeaway Media/Telecom Google
Accepting Kickbacks, Publishers Are Playing Into Tech Companies’ Hands
For years, news publishers have been clamoring for Facebook, Google and Apple to pay for the news content that gets distributed through their services.
Venture Capital Startups
Politics Create High-Wire Act for Tech CEOs
In June, after protests against the police killing of George Floyd swept the country, Glenn Kelman, CEO of online real estate brokerage Redfin, wrote an email to his customers in which he committed to doing more to help Black customers find homes in neighborhoods they’ve traditionally been shut out of.